The Dead Horse Part 2: "When the Crate is Opened"

-

 


Losses We Ignore and Big Gains They Enjoy

After the story of the dead‑horse raffle exploded, the city was suddenly flooded with narratives that sounded like propaganda: sweet on the surface, bitter underneath. Media outlets broadcast headlines that seemed to celebrate cleverness, while quietly laughing at the public’s innocence.

“Young Man Achieves Fantastic Returns!”  
“Rural Innovation Inspires the Nation!”  
“Citizens Enthusiastically Participate in Raffle!”

But the core of the story is painfully simple:  
someone turned a carcass into a business, and the public unknowingly financed it.

The Art of Making the Public Feel Nothing

This phenomenon isn’t just a tale about a dead horse.  
It’s a mirror reflecting patterns we see in governance and public life.

We are conditioned to lose small amounts:

•  tiny administrative fees,
•  deductions that “don’t matter,”
•  charges that are “only this much,”
•  policies with invisible impacts,
•  decisions that cost us quietly over time.

These small losses don’t make us angry.  
They don’t make us question anything.  
They don’t push us to act.

Because they feel trivial.

But when those tiny losses are multiplied across millions of people,  
they become enormous wealth flowing upward to a select few.

And the public?  
Still silent.  
Still obedient.  
Still buying the tickets.

What’s Inside the Crate

In this metaphor, only one person actually sees the contents of the crate.  
He posts anonymously:

“Guys… the horse was dead.”

The public reacts in predictable ways:

•  some are outraged,
•  some deny it,
•  some shrug and say “at least he got his money back,”
•  others invent conspiracy theories.

This feels very familiar.

In politics, whenever someone exposes what’s inside the “crate”—the contents of a policy, a budget, a decision—the reactions are always the same:

•  some defend,
•  some attack,
•  some pretend not to see,
•  and some create new distractions so the public forgets.

Truth often loses to noise.

When the Young Man Becomes a Symbol of Power

In the metaphor, the young city man becomes a motivational speaker.  
In real life, figures like this often become:

•  policymakers,
•  narrative controllers,
•  architects of the system,
•  or celebrated “visionaries.”

He teaches people how to turn problems into profit.  
Even problems that are already dead.

And the public pays to listen.  
Again, five thousand rupiah.  
Again, a small loss that feels harmless.

This is how power works:  
by turning public indifference into a resource.

When Satire Starts to Look Like Reality

Behind the humor and absurdity lies a political truth that’s hard to ignore:

•  The public is easy to steer when the loss is small.
•  The public stays quiet when the impact is indirect.
•  The public forgets quickly when the narrative is entertaining.
•  The public believes easily when given cheap hope.

And as long as this pattern continues,  
there will always be a new “young man from the city” ready to sell tickets,  
a new “crate” ready to be sealed,  
and a new “dead horse” ready to be monetized.

The More Dangerous Question

In the end, the important question is not:

“Why did the horse die?”

The sharper, more political, more relevant question is:

“Who keeps building the crates…  
who keeps filling them…  
and why do we keep buying the tickets?”

As long as we don’t ask,  
as long as we think “it’s only five thousand,”  
as long as we allow small losses to accumulate,  
the game will continue.

And we will remain the 999,999 silent ticket buyers.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

SUNYI DI TENGAH REPUBLIK

-
Image
  SEBUAH CERPEN SPIRITUAL SEP 2025 #SoegengPriyono #SunyiDiRepublik #IgniteHope Dalam Sunyi Aku Menemui-Nya Di antara riuh doa yang terucap,  aku memilih diam yang dalam.  Bukan karena tak tahu jalan,  tapi karena jalan itu telah menjadi aku.  Aku bukan hamba yang mencari,  aku adalah pencarian itu sendiri.  Dalam denyut nadiku,  ada nama-Nya yang tak pernah padam.  Syariat kutemui di gerak,  tapi makna kutemui di batin.  Salat bukan sekadar rukuk dan sujud,  melainkan tenggelam dalam cahaya yang menyatu.  Aku bukan langit, bukan bumi,  aku adalah titik di mana keduanya bertemu.  Di sana, aku lenyap,  dan Tuhan menjadi aku yang sejati . PROLOG Aku ingin bercerita sebuah kisah kontemplatif yang menggambarkan bagaimana seorang tokoh spiritual radikal hadir dan bertindak di tengah hiruk-pikuk politik, media sosial, dan pencarian makna zaman modern.  Di tengah suasana politik Indonesia yang kompleks—dengan ...
Read more

Jejak Imlek di Benteng Heritage

-
  1 Maret 2026 kemarin, kami mendapat kehormatan diundang oleh Bapak Udaya Halim, pendiri sekaligus ketua Yayasan Benteng Heritage, dalam perayaan Imlek. Acara ini bukan sekadar perayaan, tetapi sebuah perjalanan menelusuri jejak sejarah panjang komunitas Tionghoa di Tangerang. Sejarah Awal    Pada abad ke-14. para pendatang dari daratan Tiongkok mulai tiba di tepi Sungai Cisadane, melalui pelabuhan Teluk Naga. Lokasi yang kini menjadi bagian dari Kota Tangerang, tempat berdirinya Museum Boen Teck Bio dan Roemah Burung, sudah menjadi titik pertemuan budaya sejak ratusan tahun lalu. Konteks Nusantara    Flashback sedikit ke abad ke-14 itu adalah masa transisi besar di Nusantara. Saat Kubilai Khan mengirim pasukan Tartar ke Jawa Timur untuk menghukum Kertanegara, yang ironisnya sudah wafat dibunuh Jayakatwang. Raden Wijaya, menantu Kertanegara, memanfaatkan momentum kedatangan pasukan Monggol ini. Bersama para ksatria legendaris seperti Ario Ronggolawe, Semi, Kuti...
Read more

BUMN, Pekerjaan, dan ROI Kekuasaan

-
Image
  Saudaraku, mencari pekerjaan di negeri ini tidak pernah mudah. Skill terbatas, pengalaman minim, dan persaingan yang begitu padat membuat banyak orang merasa tersisih. Bayangkan, setiap tahun Indonesia melahirkan 700–800 ribu sarjana baru. Fresh graduates terutama harus berjuang keras, sementara profesional berpengalaman tetap menghadapi jalan terjal bila credential mereka tidak sesuai dengan posisi yang diincar. “Salah satu jalan yang dianggap menggiurkan adalah melamar ke BUMN. Konon, no offence, kultur budaya BUMN mirip birokrasi pegawai negeri, sehingga credential dari pegawai swasta yang minimpun bisa mendapatkan perhatian extra disitu. Ada pepatah lama mengatakan, " in the land of the blind, a one-eyed man is king ". Alternatif lain, tentu saja, adalah masuk ke partai politik—di mana prasyarat pendidikan dan pengalaman kerja praktis tidak menjadi hambatan. Bagi profesional swasta tingkat menengah yang kesulitan bersaing di pasar naker, peluang menggiurkan adalah mengi...
Read more